I liked the topic and would also like to give my opinion.
I love all the FIFAs ever made since 07 (For PC). I WANT to edit 11, 12 and 13 in the future, but I don't know what that will be. 12 has very fluid gameplay and is easy to pick up, but I hate the game's shots, I find them complicated without finesse.
13 makes it impossible to score headed goals, but it was my favorite for a long time: soundtrack, squads, menus, the unique layout of the game itself, the volley and cover goals... I think it's as superior as 14, which has excellent gameplay, goals from free kicks, headers and from distance are awesome in this 14, but I hate the "delay" that the dolls have. Anyone who plays 16 every day and goes to 14 haha, struggles to remember the rhythm.
The FIFA 15, I think is the GOAT in gameplay, contradicting many here. I like his base game, even though the dolls are ridiculous. The 16 is great, but it still hasn't won me over like the others mentioned. It must be because I'm getting old, without that admiration of young guy (I only played 16 in 2024 for the first time hahaha).