• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Status
Not open for further replies.

seymourtitty

Club Supporter
As a regular FIFA PC player, I have to express my disappointment at the latest installment.

The gameplay is simply atrocious and unrealistic - the ball darts around like a pinball and it is often a matter of luck if a pass or shot is successful. Hera are a list of gripes:

AI - terrible. Using the new off the ball feature, I try and pick out the player I want, but very often you cannot, he is not 1 of the 3 available players.

Random refereeing - yellow cards dished out for no reason, severe tackles go unpunished.

Awful interface - This is unbelievable - how bad are the menus? Designed by the blind for the blind, the quality is simply disgusting. For example, the final screen before a game lists the 2 line-ups - but you can only see 9 players.

Team management - Clunky and a lot of effort to swap players around - you often just want to forget it and get on with the game. But this defeats the whole object of Team Management surely?

Prestige points? What???????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Transfer window - admittedly I don't know much about FIFA's transfer system, but when I try to buy players I get the message 'Transfer window closed.' Fair enough, but shouldnt there be a message saying that the window is about to close?

Corners/free kicks - Many people have already said this - but if the foul is committed on the wing, then very often you can only shoot!!! Atrocious design. And as for the corners, these are like mini-games which bare little resemblance to the real game. They feel isolated from the match action. Good idea but dubious execution.

God, thats it for now.

Make sure you do the only sensible thing - get your money back and get Pro Evolution.

Its the first time PE has been launched on PC - and EA have had tons of attempts to perfect FIFA!!

What a joke! Konami have got it right first time, its absolutely superb.

FIFA 2004? No thanks, exit to windows. (If you can be bothered to find that option in the menus!!!)
:kader: :kader: :kader:
 

Chuny

Chairman
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
I don't think it's that bad.
I actualy like it alot, not as much as PES tho'.
But I think that the base of the gameplay is quite good, there's room for improvements, but I think the next year's game should improve the graphics (faces, kits, etc) and some little touches on the gameplay.

See ya!
 

Fire Fan

Youth Team
You know your review lacks sincerity because of your ending statement, makes me and other readers think that all you want to do is bash fifa and promote PES
 

Axelforce

Youth Team
Re: Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Originally posted by seymourtitty
As a regular FIFA PC player, I have to express my disappointment at the latest installment.

The gameplay is simply atrocious and unrealistic - the ball darts around like a pinball and it is often a matter of luck if a pass or shot is successful. Hera are a list of gripes:

AI - terrible. Using the new off the ball feature, I try and pick out the player I want, but very often you cannot, he is not 1 of the 3 available players.

Random refereeing - yellow cards dished out for no reason, severe tackles go unpunished.

Awful interface - This is unbelievable - how bad are the menus? Designed by the blind for the blind, the quality is simply disgusting. For example, the final screen before a game lists the 2 line-ups - but you can only see 9 players.

Team management - Clunky and a lot of effort to swap players around - you often just want to forget it and get on with the game. But this defeats the whole object of Team Management surely?

Prestige points? What???????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Transfer window - admittedly I don't know much about FIFA's transfer system, but when I try to buy players I get the message 'Transfer window closed.' Fair enough, but shouldnt there be a message saying that the window is about to close?

Corners/free kicks - Many people have already said this - but if the foul is committed on the wing, then very often you can only shoot!!! Atrocious design. And as for the corners, these are like mini-games which bare little resemblance to the real game. They feel isolated from the match action. Good idea but dubious execution.

God, thats it for now.

Make sure you do the only sensible thing - get your money back and get Pro Evolution.

Its the first time PE has been launched on PC - and EA have had tons of attempts to perfect FIFA!!

What a joke! Konami have got it right first time, its absolutely superb.

FIFA 2004? No thanks, exit to windows. (If you can be bothered to find that option in the menus!!!)
:kader: :kader: :kader:

*care* :)
 

seymourtitty

Club Supporter
Lacks sincerity?

My review is an honest opinion - as I said I've been playing FIFA for years, and I really wanted the game to be good.

Just played a game and gave a penalty away. John Motson says "No, he hasn't given it..the foul was just outside the box."!!!!!

Another example. John Motson, in August, says "The pitch is holding up well..normally at this time of year they can be bad."

Yeh right, pitches are always bad in August.

I really think that EA have let us down this year - the menu system encapsulates everything that is wrong with the game, sloppy, badly thought out, frustrating and simply not worth the effort.

Let's stop licking EA's arse - they've had lots of attempts to perfect FIFA now - and all they end up doing is going around in circles.

Whereas Konami have hit bullseye at the first time of asking!!!
 

machiavellian04

Reserve Team
Re: Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Originally posted by seymourtitty
As a regular FIFA PC player, I have to express my disappointment at the latest installment.

The gameplay is simply atrocious and unrealistic - the ball darts around like a pinball and it is often a matter of luck if a pass or shot is successful. Hera are a list of gripes:

AI - terrible. Using the new off the ball feature, I try and pick out the player I want, but very often you cannot, he is not 1 of the 3 available players.

Random refereeing - yellow cards dished out for no reason, severe tackles go unpunished.

Awful interface - This is unbelievable - how bad are the menus? Designed by the blind for the blind, the quality is simply disgusting. For example, the final screen before a game lists the 2 line-ups - but you can only see 9 players.

Team management - Clunky and a lot of effort to swap players around - you often just want to forget it and get on with the game. But this defeats the whole object of Team Management surely?

Prestige points? What???????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Transfer window - admittedly I don't know much about FIFA's transfer system, but when I try to buy players I get the message 'Transfer window closed.' Fair enough, but shouldnt there be a message saying that the window is about to close?

Corners/free kicks - Many people have already said this - but if the foul is committed on the wing, then very often you can only shoot!!! Atrocious design. And as for the corners, these are like mini-games which bare little resemblance to the real game. They feel isolated from the match action. Good idea but dubious execution.

God, thats it for now.

Make sure you do the only sensible thing - get your money back and get Pro Evolution.

Its the first time PE has been launched on PC - and EA have had tons of attempts to perfect FIFA!!

What a joke! Konami have got it right first time, its absolutely superb.

FIFA 2004? No thanks, exit to windows. (If you can be bothered to find that option in the menus!!!)
:kader: :kader: :kader:

A bad workman, blames his tools...

This is my diagnosis: An acute case of VD*!!























*VD: Verbal Diarrhea.

Pre-release (for the PC) propaganda? Hmmm... you haven't posted much under that name, have you! I wonder who you really are... How many accounts have you opened to bash FIFA, eh?... :/
All of this FIFA bashing looks pretty desperate- if PES 3 is so ****ing good, go and play it (or wait for the PC version to be released)- shove the game up your arse for all I care.


A lot of us enjoy playing FIFA 2004- live with it!
 

Perth Glory

Senior Squad
Fair points seymourtitty.

People if you disagree can you please elaborate?
You obviously care enough to post how much you don't care. Also, even if someone sucks at playing FIFA04 that has no bearing on the quality of FIFA04 as a representation of football.

Only a week to go now :p
 

machiavellian04

Reserve Team
Re: Lacks sincerity?

Originally posted by seymourtitty

Let's stop licking EA's arse - they've had lots of attempts to perfect FIFA now - and all they end up doing is going around in circles.

Whereas Konami have hit bullseye at the first time of asking!!!

In your opinion!
 

machiavellian04

Reserve Team
Originally posted by Perth Glory
Fair points seymourtitty.

People if you disagree can you please elaborate?
You obviously care enough to post how much you don't care. Also, even if someone sucks at playing FIFA04 that has no bearing on the quality of FIFA04 as a representation of football.

Only a week to go now :p

It's a game for Christ's sake! Go outside with some friends, for a real game of football! WTF?!
 

shokz

The Red Devil
Originally posted by Hattrickhero127
no one cares that u dont like it .. stop posting dumb Sh!t

EA will care when they relise they are no longer the benchmark's of football games.
 

Perth Glory

Senior Squad
Re: Re: Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Originally posted by machiavellian04
All of this FIFA bashing looks pretty desperate- if PES 3 is so ****ing good, go and play it (or wait for the PC version to be released)- shove the game up your arse for all I care.


A lot of us enjoy playing FIFA 2004- live with it!

I think you're getting desperation and exasperation mixed up.

As a football simulation, as the EA hype machine claims it to be, the FIFA series has been in a slump since FIFA98 and is only just starting to slowly climb its way out.
Alot of people this year seem to have had enough. It's better than 03, which is nice and all, but that does not, for me, make the game worth buying. All of seymour's points are fair and the list is far from complete.

This is all talking as a football simulation. If people like FIFA04 there is no reason for me to have a problem with that.
 

shevadk

Club Supporter
Have you ever played soccer in real life.. then you would know that FIFA 2004 is the best and most realistic football simulation ever made..
And I would like to comment some of your outbursts
1. Transfer Window.. If you don't know when the Transfer Window closes then you do not pay attention to the football world
2. Final screen before match: have you tried clicking on one of the players and then moove down.. YOU CAN SWITCH PLAYERS IF YOU WANT TO MAKE YOUR LINE UP BETTER... Are you really that stupid.
3. Passes and shots. If you cannot make passes and shots then let me tell you one thing: IT's NOT THE GAME THAT MAKES THE PASSES.. IT's YOU: STUPID...
And when your playing follow this rule:
KISS
Keep
It
Simple
Stupid
4. The Freekicks and corners have never been better.. Then if you have not played in real life.. you wouldn't know..

And I think there is many out there who wil agree with me
DON'T WRITE SUTCH STUPID POSTS AGAIN..
 

machiavellian04

Reserve Team
Re: Re: Re: Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Originally posted by Perth Glory
If people like FIFA04 there is no reason for me to have a problem with that.

Great, that's a good attitude to have. Like I said in a previous posting: One man's pleasure, is another man's poison.

Life would be boring if we all liked (and disliked) the same things. If people hate FIFA, then fine- but 'reviewers' need to realise that they are mearly imparting their personal opinions. They are not (in most cases) statements of fact.
 

Perth Glory

Senior Squad
Originally posted by machiavellian04
It's a game for Christ's sake! Go outside with some friends, for a real game of football! WTF?!
It's summer here now, season's over :p
In my spare time I want to play the best vitual representation of the game, so I don't play FIFA04.
Like I said if you like FIFA, that's fine too.
 

machiavellian04

Reserve Team
Originally posted by Perth Glory
It's summer here now, season's over :p
In my spare time I want to play the best vitual representation of the game, so I don't play FIFA04.
Like I said if you like FIFA, that's fine too.

Smashing! :P
 

Perth Glory

Senior Squad
Re: Re: Re: Re: Truly Disgusting - Get Pro Evolution

Originally posted by machiavellian04
Great, that's a good attitude to have. Like I said in a previous posting: One man's pleasure, is another man's poison.

Life would be boring if we all liked (and disliked) the same things. If people hate FIFA, then fine- but 'reviewers' need to realise that they are mearly imparting their personal opinions. They are not (in most cases) statements of fact.
Yup, can't disagree with that. We're all just posting opinionated BS, and we all know there are at least a thousand more contructive things we could be doing instead ;)
 

O-car

Starting XI
god damn it, haven´t we seen enough of these fifa bashing threads?if you don´t like the game, don´t play it! simple as that. stop posting these whining threads, "fifa suck""ea doesn´t care" buhuhu. I know fifa isn´t the best game in the world, it takes a while to get used to though.Personally I think the game is great. nice gameplay, good graphics. If you have the need to praise PES 3, please find some PES 3 forums to do that in. in case you didn´t notice, this is a fifa forum. no need to bash ea and fifa all the time in these threads
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Top