Voting isn't closed, so if you haven't participated yet go ahead. Positions thus far...
Civilization II - 11 votes (Tom, Anthony, Dragan T, Mandieta6, rpvankasteren*, Ruben Sosa, Filipower, proxnet, Kibe Kru, Zlatan, ScimitarPES2)
GTA II - 11 votes (Anthony, Dragan T, Mandieta6, nor-rbk, night, Horatiu, Massive, skiptomylou, proxnet, shokz, Zlatan)
Midtown Madness - 9 votes (Anthony, Dragan T, nor-rbk, night, Filipower, Horatiu, Massive, Zlatan, ScimitarPES2)
Rome: Total War - 9 votes (Tom, Anthony, Dragan T, Mandieta6, rpvankasteren*, Filipower, Kibe Kru, Zlatan, VprArs06)
-------------------------
Super Smash Bros - 8 votes (Mandieta6, Ruben Sosa, Filipower, Horatiu, skiptomylou, proxnet, VprArs06, ScimitarPES2)
Winning Eleven 6 - 7 votes (nor-rbk, Ruben Sosa, night, Horatiu, Massive, skiptomylou, shokz)
Grim Fandango - 6 votes (Tom, rpvankasteren*, Ruben Sosa, night, Massive, shokz)
Halo 2 - 6 votes (Tom, nor-rbk, skiptomylou, proxnet, VprArs06, ScimitarPES2)
Bricks - 2 votes (Kibe Kru, VprArs06)
Low G Man - 2 votes (Kibe Kru, VprArs06)
* = Rpvankasteren voted for 3 games (twice for Grim, only counted 1).