This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:
1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.
2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.
3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.
Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.
Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.
Thank you!
Socrates;2435210 said:IMO Metz has looked more solid than Heinze has and he is also better in the air which helps out against teams that use the long ball like Mallorca did today. I think right now our weakest CB is Cannavaro. Also I would not mind a backline of
Ramos--Pepe--Metz--Marcelo
Marcelo has been pretty good at defending thus far, apart from this game of course but it seemed like the whole defence was not set up right today so I won't play too much importance on his weak defense today.
KingPaulV;2435670 said:I know wasnt that video just chilling to the bone!, awesome stuff, hopefully thought this year we can be celebrating La liga with at least two or three games left, y la decima also!
about Robihno and Gago...
I believe in one of the most accurate commentaries I heard on Robihno, the guy mentioned that Robihno is the type of footballer who needs to get treated right, like royalty, he needs to be the protagonist, the main guy and when that happens then nobody can stop the guy. Right now, (as it happened in Copa America) Schuster has told him "You are the IT guy; the team goes thru you" and look how he has been responding; The tons of potential that Robihno has are unlimited; However as with many Brazilians we need to watch for the on and off, attitude of character that he may have, so that when the off time comes he doesnt get overly critisized....Either way, I love how he is playing, he is the reference point; like some years ago they used to call us Raul Madrid, now we could very easily Turn into the Robihno Madrid...hehe
Gago; the guy is improving with every game, and so is marcelo, but I still dont like Marcelo's defending, is very lax and suspect, and I can attribute that to youth, if we take care of him and handle him properly he should also be great for us...
I have a bigger question for you guys:
What about the signings? Do you guys realize that most of our success is coming from the guys that have always been there or Capello's team as some people say; Cause to be honest, apart from Pepe (who was phenomenal yesterday IMO) I dont see where the money went. I dont know what is wrong with Wesley except that I think he is playing out of position and cannot find his place in this system....Saviola doesnt have a place with an in-form Raul as it has been all year. Drenthe was too young IMO he was unproven and we are paying that price; and Robben, well he is made out of glass, 36 mill down the drain, another Woodgate....Heinze and Pepe the two defenders are the only ones that I see production out of as it was expected
OrgulloVikingo;2435801 said:I hope Pepe will be worth his price. I really don't get why you rate Royston! Perhaps cause he looks like Edgar Davids? I don't know. He's already getting p!ssed off cause he has to ride the bench and he hasn't even been here for 3 months! I hope he's not another premadonna. To me, he has everything to prove. He should sit and be quiet and try to learn from the others and work hard. On Saviola, I forgot we got him on the free. You are right, good to have him waiting around just in case Ruud, Raul get injured, die or get redcarded, etc. Right on bout Wesley, he's class. The last thing he needs is being critisized to death. Pepe and Metz make the best pair in the middle. Heinze, solid buy! Robben? Silly buy. When fit, he's explosive, dominates the ball and takes it to people with determination, and dives a bit too Unfortunately, I very much doubt he can remain healthy for more than a month at a time, and we're not even talking about getting rythym, absorbing the chemistry and adjusting to everything! I give our purchases this season, so far a 3.25/5
Moreira_Benfica;2435856 said:how did pepe play
KingPaulV;2435827 said:I agree with that score, only thing I differ with you guys is that althought I love both Metzelder and Heinze, I would rate Heinze a little higher, he's just a blue collar players, very hard working, and a wise old dog there, in the defense...If we can cut out all the silly marking mistakes we are making in the back we can be solid, IMO our biggest backline problem is we are allowing too many shots in front of goal, by not closing down rebounds; We are doing a horrible job of marking set pieces/Corners; We give our backs to overlapping runs, way too easily....
Metz has had serious lapses at times with his Marking giving his back away and such, and althought Heinze seems a little crazy at times, he is wise, knows where to clear and has regained some of the form that had made him when he first got to Man U one of the best Defenders in the world....overall both are great buys!
i disagree with u on cannavaro. he has been the only centre back that has bee consistent so far this season for us.Socrates;2435895 said:I don't know, so far I perfer Heinze on the left rather than the CB, he also seems to be a thug at times so that can hurt us bad especally in CB position where it's easy to give away a PK or a very deadly FK aswell as getting red carded. I also think part of the reason for our bad marking on the corners/set pieces in the Mallorca game was that niether Cannavaro or Heinze can dominate in the air while both Pepe and Metz does that ( he won every header vs El Moro who is a very good target man that wins a lot of headers ), Ramos also would have been useful but we could not use him. Against Mallorca we only had Diarra and Ruud who could really win the headers. Even with that Mallorca scored on 2 defence errors and a golazo so take that for what it's worth.
Indeed both are very good players but for me Metz seems like a more solid bet, I have so far not seen these lapses he has had in defence and he seems to be able to really dominate for us so far. Either way it's nice that we have both of them because already we have had some bad injuries in defence for us so it's good cover to have. I also want to mention that Metz has really suprised me, I thought he would be the weakest CB but he is truning out to be one of the best actually.
Deisler - Have you seen Canna play for us? He has been the weakest defender thus far and is only getting older. Right now for me at least, everyone is ahead of him in the pecking order of CB's that we have.
Moreira_Benfica - Like Paul said, he is was great. Hopefully he does just as well for you guys.
If Ramos has a lot to learn, then we have in potential the best defender of all time in our squad. lol. I think that Ramos is as good as a CB as a RB. He is atm better than all our defenders, no doubt. He wins every header, he is freakin fast, he has the best sliding tackle in the country and has a very good shot/cross. And dont let me begin on his technique, if you look at the kid you would think he is an attacker. he posseses fantastic technique. I remember him doing step overs, zidane spins etc. His ball control is perfect. In short, we would miss Ramos more than any player in the back line.Jaouadinho;2436023 said:i do rate metzelder and ramos very hihgly but i would prefer pepe and cannavaro to both of them.
matz isnt that convinsing he is a good sub to have. and ramos still has a lot to learn and he is more usefull to us at right back.
justhammy;2436475 said:If Ramos has a lot to learn, then we have in potential the best defender of all time in our squad. lol. I think that Ramos is as good as a CB as a RB. He is atm better than all our defenders, no doubt. He wins every header, he is freakin fast, he has the best sliding tackle in the country and has a very good shot/cross. And dont let me begin on his technique, if you look at the kid you would think he is an attacker. he posseses fantastic technique. I remember him doing step overs, zidane spins etc. His ball control is perfect. In short, we would miss Ramos more than any player in the back line.
No bad words about those other players btw. Pepe is a superb player. Metze is very stable, he doesnt make many mistakes. Cannavaro has experience and is a true leader. Heinze can set up the defense like no one else. Marcelo is a gem. Same goes for Torres. So as you can read, I'm a very happy guy. Obvious if you have those names at the back
i wasnt saying he is isnt good ofcorse he is good one of the best in the world probably. but he still needs a bit more experience i.e positioning and the rest of it.justhammy;2436475 said:If Ramos has a lot to learn, then we have in potential the best defender of all time in our squad. lol. I think that Ramos is as good as a CB as a RB. He is atm better than all our defenders, no doubt. He wins every header, he is freakin fast, he has the best sliding tackle in the country and has a very good shot/cross. And dont let me begin on his technique, if you look at the kid you would think he is an attacker. he posseses fantastic technique. I remember him doing step overs, zidane spins etc. His ball control is perfect. In short, we would miss Ramos more than any player in the back line.
No bad words about those other players btw. Pepe is a superb player. Metze is very stable, he doesnt make many mistakes. Cannavaro has experience and is a true leader. Heinze can set up the defense like no one else. Marcelo is a gem. Same goes for Torres. So as you can read, I'm a very happy guy. Obvious if you have those names at the back