Pato vs Benzema..

[zizou89]

Which of the 2 do you prefer and why?
Both in great form at the moment..

But for me Pato > Benzema.

 

[thelordspawn]

Benzenma sucks he is by far the most overrated striker atm he plays in a joke league on a team thats won like 20 league titles in a row cuase all the other teams suck theres only 1 other good team in ligue 1 in marseille come to real leaguelike epl or spain then u can really judge how good he is when facing the tops clubs in world and pato is decent nothing special yet

 

[thetrooper37]

Definitely Pato > Benzema

 

[Awax]

Both are very talented, but Benzema has yet to prove himself in a 'better' league.

 

[rony31]

Given current form I'd say Pato. Benzema's definitely a talent though, we've seen what he's capable of in the CL, and he's close to a move to a major team (aka City)

 

[lucacalciatore]

Completely agree with Rony.

 

[mnj2x]

Benzenma sucks he is by far the most overrated striker atm he plays in a joke league on a team thats won like 20 league titles in a row cuase all the other teams suck theres only 1 other good team in ligue 1 in marseille come to real leaguelike epl or spain then u can really judge how good he is when facing the tops clubs in world and pato is decent nothing special yet

going by that theory... All Lyon players SUCK to the core. yes even juninho, (arguably the best at free kicks in the world)

 

[Bad Gon17]

going by that theory... All Lyon players SUCK to the core. yes even juninho, (arguably the best at free kicks in the world)

Lyon do not suck last year Manu score last minute goal in one game and only beat us in he other because Crisiano Ronaldo is so good if he didnt play in your team they would not have won th champions league what about the seasons lyon beat real madrid 3-0 then 2-0 again the next season just to prove it wasnt a fluke lyon just do not have the funds to keep their players so they all go to the bigger clubs were the money is if lyon kept their players they could easily take manu any day
oh and Benzema is better than pato

 

[abyPREDATOR]

Pato. Benzema is pretty much useless in the big matches.

 

[Zlatan]

Benzema for sure...the only bright spot in the French NT during EURO 2008. France has a very talented squad anyway with besides Benzema also the likes of Nasri, Gourcuff, Ben Arfa etc.

 

[ShiftyPowers]

From that joke league there has been thousand of fantastic players.

I can name just Zidane. For those who understand football is enough.

Zidane the best AM of his generation. Desailly the best DM of his generation. Hundreds more.

 

[Bad Gon17]

Pato. Benzema is pretty much useless in the big matches.

Pato maybe but not Benzema

 

[Deni_Rossonero]

I see a limit in quality in Benzema, i think he will be a superstar but he won't ever grow to be the best player in the world, while Pato has that potential. Remember this is Pato's first full season with Milan, and he's been in better form than both Ronaldinho and Kaka' this year. But there's no doubt that Benzema is a top class talent.

 

[mnj2x]

Lyon do not suck last year Manu score last minute goal in one game and only beat us in he other because Crisiano Ronaldo is so good if he didnt play in your team they would not have won th champions league what about the seasons lyon beat real madrid 3-0 then 2-0 again the next season just to prove it wasnt a fluke lyon just do not have the funds to keep their players so they all go to the bigger clubs were the money is if lyon kept their players they could easily take manu any day
oh and Benzema is better than pato

dude..i think u misunderstood my post. I was being sarcastic to the guy who said benzema sux and the french league is a useless league.

 

[thelordspawn]

From that joke league there has been thousand of fantastic players.

I can name just Zidane. For those who understand football is enough.

1 superstar/really really good player doesnt make a league "not a joke league"

 

[Arnau]

well Shifty named one more.

I said, I can name thousands of them.

Henry, one of the three best strikers of his generation for sure, a lot others,....

Don't forget. France were World & European Champion with those players. All went through their 'joke league'.

Ribery, Evra, Yaya Toure, ... new era

eeeh you are cana lover and he is OM player ok but that dont mean ligue 1 is ****, its an exporter league, the club sells his best players, doenst has level.

 

[Arnau]

i'm not saying they are ****, his league is.

 

[Bobby]

Patrick Vieira is and has always been a ****ty footballer.

You know another crappy player? Eric Cantona.

Oh.

 

[kp41]

at the moment Pato's doing better, but Karim Benzema is more complete player.

 

[Sevillista]

I have to agree, until Benzema proves himself with the French NT or in a better league, I will be skeptical. He didn't do much with the time he played in Euro2008, though that French NT made a lot of good players look bad.

And I think what people are trying to say is that "playing well" in the French league doesn't necessarily mean they will be superstars in top leagues. They certainly could be, as many French players have done, but they are unproven until they move.