I think is better when you make manual freestyle moves because in Fifa 2003 i moved the analog stick and most of the time I just gave the ball to the other team. (Moved the ball forward and since the deffender is so close to me, he would just take the ball away from me), also when you moved the analog stick, you had to slow down in order for the player to do the freestyle move and takes so long to do the move that the other team takes the ball away from you very easy.
Therefore EA should make the freestyle moves like in WC98, where you had a conbination of pressing one of the shoulder buttons and one of the 4 buttons (triangle,square,circle,and X), which will make like 8 moves and the advantage of choosing your move is that you will make the move that will help you get a marker out of your way for the specific situation, and not move the analog stick and perform a move that would just give the ball to the other team.
I don't know why EA introduced the Freestyle control for Fifa 2003 if I only passed my marker twice and the rest of the times I tried, which were about 1,000, ended in the other team's player.
Therefore EA should make the freestyle moves like in WC98, where you had a conbination of pressing one of the shoulder buttons and one of the 4 buttons (triangle,square,circle,and X), which will make like 8 moves and the advantage of choosing your move is that you will make the move that will help you get a marker out of your way for the specific situation, and not move the analog stick and perform a move that would just give the ball to the other team.
I don't know why EA introduced the Freestyle control for Fifa 2003 if I only passed my marker twice and the rest of the times I tried, which were about 1,000, ended in the other team's player.