• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

La Liga 2009/2010

Sevillista

Starting XI
KingPaulV;2808767 said:
Humm, so you want a 'La Liga' Thread so you can talk about Real Madrid, and how evil their players and their institution is?....Go to the Madrid thread they already do that quite well there....what a joke..
Ronaldo's suspension is the top story in La Liga right now... seemed like a good place to start.

Arnau, buti, while Athletic has a great history and tradition, I hate Caparros and their style of play. Los leones? More like los guarros. But it's hard to imagine La Liga without them.

Mandieta6, of course La Liga vs Premier League is very subjective. But I think that the mid table teams in Spain are better... based on years of greater success in the UEFA Cup and head-to-head exhibition matches. I also think Spain produces much more homegrown talent.
 

Pogba4Now

Team Captain
Sevillista;2808807 said:
Mandieta6, of course La Liga vs Premier League is very subjective. But I think that the mid table teams in Spain are better... based on years of greater success in the UEFA Cup and head-to-head exhibition matches. I also think Spain produces much more homegrown talent.

I also think so. However this season these mid table teams in the EPL are getting even better. Aston Villa, Tottenham and City are emerging as very good teams compared as last season. And I don't think teams like Valencia and Villareal are as good now as they were 2-3 years ago. Mid teams in La Liga are still a bit better right now though.
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
The reason I didn't go on and on is because that's what you think, and I disagree on every point. Spanish youngsters are brought up with technique as the focal point, English players are instilled with the proper mentality and physical training. That's why England has fewer dribblers and more workhorses. The thing is, wonderkids are valued for their skills, it's also why so few wonderkids really make it. The Spanish national side is a collection of successful wonderkids, and that's fantastic, the English national team has a horde of players who know the game inside-out and have the proper mentality. Spain's current generation is excellent, but Spain has also underperformed at every competition since the 80's I believe, barring the Euros. England, I think, have been more consistent, although not necessarily good. Skill is fleeting, and you can't teach the talent that Spanish youth coaches work to improve. But you can teach mentality. That's why Spain will probably continue to oscillate between greatness and mediocrity, kept up by the star players for every generation, whereas England will continue to be good but not great.

Spain does have more Spanish players at the top than England has English ones. I dunno why that is a good thing, though.

I'll just continue to disagree with the notion that the midtable Spanish sides are better. Birmingham are a recently-promoted side challenging for Europe in the closest season in recent years. Can't see that happening in Spain.
 

Sevillista

Starting XI
Nady;2808814 said:
I also think so. However this season these mid table teams in the EPL are getting even better. Aston Villa, Tottenham and City are emerging as very good teams compared as last season. And I don't think teams like Valencia and Villareal are as good now as they were 2-3 years ago. Mid teams in La Liga are still a bit better right now though.
Valencia are very good this season, I think, and have one of the best attacks in Europe. Villa, David Silva, Mata. Villareal have tons of talent too (Cazorla, Senna, Joseba Llorente, Cani, Pires), but always seem to stumble in the beginning of the season and then tear it up in the last 15 weeks.

Mandieta6;2808816 said:
Spain does have more Spanish players at the top than England has English ones. I dunno why that is a good thing, though.

I'll just continue to disagree with the notion that the midtable Spanish sides are better.
Of course we're going to disagree, but that's the kind of discussion that I was hoping to generate. And you're one of the few members left here who is opinionated and knows how to articulate your thoughts in good English :D

You don't know why it's a good thing that Spain is generating more good Spanish players than English players? I think it's fascinating to watch the homegrown talent make names for themselves. For example, Canales is quickly becoming a force in Spanish (and soon to be international) soccer. Young talent is popping up everywhere. Pablo Hernandez, Fernando Llorente, Sergio Canales, Bojan, Iker Muiain, Pedro Rodriguez, Diego Perrotti (Argentinian... but from Sevilla's youth system), Alvaro Negredo. These are just the exciting ones, or as you would call them, the "wonderkids", but I don't think there is any shortage of physical/fundamental talent.

And not to doubt you, but name some of the "workhorses" that you claim the EPL is generating. From what I've seen from the EPL (which is admittedly not that much in the past few months), I get the impression that the matches are more open and entertaining because the Spanish tend to be more "destructive" in their defensive schemes and the English more tolerant. I'm not saying that that's a good thing (I hate destructive footballing), but I stand by my opinion that La Liga has more talent.

Mandieta6;2808816 said:
Birmingham are a recently-promoted side challenging for Europe in the closest season in recent years. Can't see that happening in Spain.
That's not uncommon in La Liga at all. Last season, newly-promoted Malaga were in UEFA spots for much of the season until the last couple of weeks. The season prior, newly-promoted Almeria did the same thing. The season before that, newly-promoted Recreativo fought for the UEFA as well. This is the first season in a while that the newly promoted teams haven't done well at all.
 

Arnau

NGR LVR
Sevillista;2808807 said:
while Athletic has a great history and tradition, I hate Caparros and their style of play. Los leones? More like los guarros.

This is Athletic identity! unique and genuine but dirty team. Mendilibar was the only one who try to change their style and were sacked at week 3 lol.
 

Arnau

NGR LVR
Its funny how the people affirm convinced that it was clearly intentional/clearly unintentional, only Cristiano knows that.
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
Sevillista;2808817 said:
Valencia are very good this season, I think, and have one of the best attacks in Europe. Villa, David Silva, Mata. Villareal have tons of talent too (Cazorla, Senna, Joseba Llorente, Cani, Pires), but always seem to stumble in the beginning of the season and then tear it up in the last 15 weeks.


Of course we're going to disagree, but that's the kind of discussion that I was hoping to generate. And you're one of the few members left here who is opinionated and knows how to articulate your thoughts in good English :D

You don't know why it's a good thing that Spain is generating more good Spanish players than English players? I think it's fascinating to watch the homegrown talent make names for themselves. For example, Canales is quickly becoming a force in Spanish (and soon to be international) soccer. Young talent is popping up everywhere. Pablo Hernandez, Fernando Llorente, Sergio Canales, Bojan, Iker Muiain, Pedro Rodriguez, Diego Perrotti (Argentinian... but from Sevilla's youth system), Alvaro Negredo. These are just the exciting ones, or as you would call them, the "wonderkids", but I don't think there is any shortage of physical/fundamental talent.

And not to doubt you, but name some of the "workhorses" that you claim the EPL is generating. From what I've seen from the EPL (which is admittedly not that much in the past few months), I get the impression that the matches are more open and entertaining because the Spanish tend to be more "destructive" in their defensive schemes and the English more tolerant. I'm not saying that that's a good thing (I hate destructive footballing), but I stand by my opinion that La Liga has more talent.


That's not uncommon in La Liga at all. Last season, newly-promoted Malaga were in UEFA spots for much of the season until the last couple of weeks. The season prior, newly-promoted Almeria did the same thing. The season before that, newly-promoted Recreativo fought for the UEFA as well. This is the first season in a while that the newly promoted teams haven't done well at all.

Canales is not a major force anywhere. He's an overhyped wonderkid. The point about wonderkids is that most of them never reach their potential. Every year Spain has a bunch of players who look like they'´ll become world-class and some of them do, but most of them don't. We'll talk about Canales and Bojan when they really achieve something. I hate the fact that when a young kid scores a goal he's immediately one to watch. Same **** happened with Walcott and Rooney, although Rooney was actually worth the hype.

England has very few starlets like that, so no, I can't name a few. My point about the differences between Spanish and English training is that Spain has more talented wonderkids, but England has more hard-working adults. Those talented young Spaniards fizzle out, but the English players who had discipline instilled in them become great talents. Admittedly, the best players will always be talented for the get-go, but guys Lampard or Gerrard were never so overhyped, and their best quality is their hard-work. I remember Barton bragging about waking up at 6 am to do his running and Lamps said he and Stevie G had been waking up at 5 am every day since they were 14.

If you took out the very best players from every league, I think England would beat Spain easily, and they can/ beat them with them, too. No Lampard? You've got Bullard, Davies, Jenas, etc. These are good, not outstanding players, who are very well-rounded. Most of the Spanish side is made up of people who were wonderkids and made the step-up. Like I said, it takes one generation to have more flops than usual and England will overtake Spain. Personally, I think Spanish players peak earlier than English. Looking at the two squads' recent call-ups, Spain has many under-25s, and England has quite a few 30+'s.

I'm not saying either is bad or good. But, I suppose the preference is whether you'd rather have 20 fantastic players and 80 crappy players or 10 fantastic players and 90 average players, to be extremely 'hyperbolic'. Basically, a typical Spanish player will be technically sound and be a good player until his late 20's, and then quickly fade away. An english players will not be as good at first,. but will keep improving until and start fading away in his early 30's. Longer shelf-life, in a way.

So yes, Spain has a lot of young talent, England has more dependable players, IMO. And I LOVE the diversity in England. I remember that when I had Fifa 2003, I would sell all the Spanish, English, French, Italian and German players and make the best possible squads using the less-represented nationalities. I like seeing all those players from all sorts of places in one league. Spain defenitely has a greater emphasis on home-grown (which I think has something to do with the intrinsic racism in the culture), but I wouldn't say that's better. More competition makes the league better, and I find the notion that the Spanish league has the best players debatable. Keep Ronaldo, Messi, Kaka, etc.

I think we had this debate before, in one of the award-threads.

EDIT: Buti, for ****'s sake. Messi doesn't hit his face because he just can't. Raising your elbow just 10 cm means moving your arm akwardly, not to mention that it would require him to WANT and WILLFULLY hit the Sevilla player in the face, which he doesn't want. If the Sevilla player was shorter, or stooped like the Malaga player was, he could have accidentally hit him in the face. But he didn't. Ronaldo didnn't intended to hit him in the face, why would he? The ref is in his line of sight, he has the ball, it is all in his favor, and as he tries to cut loose, he accidentally hits him in the face. And the physical aspects of the incident have everything to do with it.

My point was that you're only demonising Ronaldo because he is Ronaldo. Just like you're making Messi out to be an angel because he's Messi. It's always been clear that you're a crest before logic sort of person, but you're just being ridiculous.

bybuti;2809179 said:
And I find it really stupid how Madrid took Messi's example to defend Ronaldo's act. Messi and Ronaldo acts are totally different one. Unless, you take Messi's case to teach Ronaldo how to behave.


And no, this isn't subjective. It is very obvious.

They are very similar acts with different consecuences. Yes, it shouldn't be subjective, it is very obvious, you're just mistaken. Can't believe you actually think you're being objective here.

RE-EDIT: Forgot the rest of Sevillista's post. Don't know what you mean as destructive football, care to explain? Anyway, I find back-and-forth footie, end-to-end chances very entertaining, and the physical prowess of English players makes that possible. Only matches I´ve een in which I was actually entertained for 20 straight matches were Valencia - MAdrid and Valencia - Barca, because, credit to them, they kept attacking and there was chance after chance. That happens at all levels in England, barring when teams park the bus, in which case it's more like a regular Barca match, which is boring IMO.

I don't rate Almeria, personally, or Malaga. But, whatever.
 

Coruja

Senior Squad
Mandieta6;2808725 said:
Consecuences should not affect punishment, intent should. Ronaldo's and Messi's intent is the same, Ronaldo is simply stronger, taller and the victim is shorter. Frankly, I don't care if he gets a red or a yellow or nothing. If he wasn't Ronaldo you wouldn't be making such a big deal out of it.

100% agreed!

Its stupid compare this things, but if Messi was as taller as Ronaldo, probably he would hit the face as well. But i laughed hard when the press used Messi's one to compare with Ronaldo. xD
 

ArgVega

Yellow Card - Racism; Exp. 31/08/2013
Mandieta6;2809186 said:
Canales is not a major force anywhere. He's an overhyped wonderkid. The point about wonderkids is that most of them never reach their potential. Every year Spain has a bunch of players who look like they'´ll become world-class and some of them do, but most of them don't. We'll talk about Canales and Bojan when they really achieve something. I hate the fact that when a young kid scores a goal he's immediately one to watch. Same **** happened with Walcott and Rooney, although Rooney was actually worth the hype.

England has very few starlets like that, so no, I can't name a few. My point about the differences between Spanish and English training is that Spain has more talented wonderkids, but England has more hard-working adults. Those talented young Spaniards fizzle out, but the English players who had discipline instilled in them become great talents. Admittedly, the best players will always be talented for the get-go, but guys Lampard or Gerrard were never so overhyped, and their best quality is their hard-work. I remember Barton bragging about waking up at 6 am to do his running and Lamps said he and Stevie G had been waking up at 5 am every day since they were 14.

If you took out the very best players from every league, I think England would beat Spain easily, and they can/ beat them with them, too. No Lampard? You've got Bullard, Davies, Jenas, etc. These are good, not outstanding players, who are very well-rounded. Most of the Spanish side is made up of people who were wonderkids and made the step-up. Like I said, it takes one generation to have more flops than usual and England will overtake Spain. Personally, I think Spanish players peak earlier than English. Looking at the two squads' recent call-ups, Spain has many under-25s, and England has quite a few 30+'s.

I'm not saying either is bad or good. But, I suppose the preference is whether you'd rather have 20 fantastic players and 80 crappy players or 10 fantastic players and 90 average players, to be extremely 'hyperbolic'. Basically, a typical Spanish player will be technically sound and be a good player until his late 20's, and then quickly fade away. An english players will not be as good at first,. but will keep improving until and start fading away in his early 30's. Longer shelf-life, in a way.

So yes, Spain has a lot of young talent, England has more dependable players, IMO. And I LOVE the diversity in England. I remember that when I had Fifa 2003, I would sell all the Spanish, English, French, Italian and German players and make the best possible squads using the less-represented nationalities. I like seeing all those players from all sorts of places in one league. Spain defenitely has a greater emphasis on home-grown (which I think has something to do with the intrinsic racism in the culture), but I wouldn't say that's better. More competition makes the league better, and I find the notion that the Spanish league has the best players debatable. Keep Ronaldo, Messi, Kaka, etc.

I think we had this debate before, in one of the award-threads.

EDIT: Buti, for ****'s sake. Messi doesn't hit his face because he just can't. Raising your elbow just 10 cm means moving your arm akwardly, not to mention that it would require him to WANT and WILLFULLY hit the Sevilla player in the face, which he doesn't want. If the Sevilla player was shorter, or stooped like the Malaga player was, he could have accidentally hit him in the face. But he didn't. Ronaldo didnn't intended to hit him in the face, why would he? The ref is in his line of sight, he has the ball, it is all in his favor, and as he tries to cut loose, he accidentally hits him in the face. And the physical aspects of the incident have everything to do with it.

My point was that you're only demonising Ronaldo because he is Ronaldo. Just like you're making Messi out to be an angel because he's Messi. It's always been clear that you're a crest before logic sort of person, but you're just being ridiculous.



They are very similar acts with different consecuences. Yes, it shouldn't be subjective, it is very obvious, you're just mistaken. Can't believe you actually think you're being objective here.

RE-EDIT: Forgot the rest of Sevillista's post. Don't know what you mean as destructive football, care to explain? Anyway, I find back-and-forth footie, end-to-end chances very entertaining, and the physical prowess of English players makes that possible. Only matches I´ve een in which I was actually entertained for 20 straight matches were Valencia - MAdrid and Valencia - Barca, because, credit to them, they kept attacking and there was chance after chance. That happens at all levels in England, barring when teams park the bus, in which case it's more like a regular Barca match, which is boring IMO.

I don't rate Almeria, personally, or Malaga. But, whatever.


I think its all subjective and the english will have their reasons why its better and the spanish will have their resons why its better, but at the end of the day i'd say its closer to neck and neck than anything else...

you can say competition makes leagues better, but define competition, competition for the uefa spots? competition for title? If you look at both team tables right now:

spains 4-10 spots are alot closer in terms of points to each other, than englands 4-10 spots

england has 3 within 2 points at the top, spain has 3 within 10 points

it all depends on what you value or look at in a league, no one is better than the other in general, its only in certain aspects or points that the leagues beat one another...

so yeah we'll stay with
messi, ronaldo, kaka, ibrahimovic, david villa, iniesta, xavi

and you can keep
lampard, gerrard, rooney, torres, cesc

(Y)
 

KingPaulV

Starting XI
Gooolazo by Canales, great little young player I hope he keeps developing nicely....Thoughts of Julen Guerrero come to mind
 

Sevillista

Starting XI
Mandieta6;2809186 said:
Canales is not a major force anywhere. He's an overhyped wonderkid.
Canales is a major force somewhere, namely a city called Santander. He has the team and fans excited and winning. They're 8-2-1 in their last eleven matches since he started tearing it up, and you know he doesn't have much of a team behind him.

Mandieta6;2809186 said:
The point about wonderkids is that most of them never reach their potential. Every year Spain has a bunch of players who look like they'´ll become world-class and some of them do, but most of them don't. We'll talk about Canales and Bojan when they really achieve something.
Or you can have fun watching them while they're lighting it up. Even if they don't reach their potential, in your words there are new wonderkids every season. Why discredit what they're doing now based on hypothetical future flops?

Mandieta6 said:
England has more hard-working adults. Those talented young Spaniards fizzle out, but the English players who had discipline instilled in them become great talents....

...If you took out the very best players from every league, I think England would beat Spain easily, and they can/ beat them with them, too. No Lampard? You've got Bullard, Davies, Jenas, etc. These are good, not outstanding players, who are very well-rounded. Most of the Spanish side is made up of people who were wonderkids and made the step-up. Like I said, it takes one generation to have more flops than usual and England will overtake Spain. Personally, I think Spanish players peak earlier than English. Looking at the two squads' recent call-ups, Spain has many under-25s, and England has quite a few 30+'s.

I'm not saying either is bad or good. But, I suppose the preference is whether you'd rather have 20 fantastic players and 80 crappy players or 10 fantastic players and 90 average players, to be extremely 'hyperbolic'. Basically, a typical Spanish player will be technically sound and be a good player until his late 20's, and then quickly fade away. An english players will not be as good at first,. but will keep improving until and start fading away in his early 30's. Longer shelf-life, in a way.

So yes, Spain has a lot of young talent, England has more dependable players, IMO.

All of these arguments are generalized or based on a hypothetical future. Just because Spain has a lot of "wonderkids" doesn't mean they don't have dependable/disciplined/well-rounded players. Both leagues have them in spades. You seriously think 80% of La Liga's players are "crappy" and 90% of England's players are average?. Then there is no point in discussing this with you anymore.

England's NT may have older players, but where has that gotten them? You argue that Spain goes through cycles and by comparison England has more stability. What is that based on? England has not had more success than Spain, unless you want to go back to 1966.

And I LOVE the diversity in England. I remember that when I had Fifa 2003. Spain defenitely has a greater emphasis on home-grown (which I think has something to do with the intrinsic racism in the culture), but I wouldn't say that's better.
Again, you're stating something that is "definite", but you have nothing to back up your argument. What makes you say the EPL is more diverse? Sevilla, for example, has players from Mali, Serbia, Lithuania, Ivory Coast, France, Brazil, and Argentina. We have better homegrown talent, but that doesn't mean we have an excess of it. Spanish soccer is very diverse:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_foreign_La_Liga_players

Mandieta6 said:
Don't know what you mean as destructive football, care to explain?
What I mean is that the game is much tighter, allowing fewer passing lanes.

Mandieta6 said:
Anyway, I find back-and-forth footie, end-to-end chances very entertaining, and the physical prowess of English players makes that possible. Only matches I´ve een in which I was actually entertained for 20 straight matches were Valencia - MAdrid and Valencia - Barca, because, credit to them, they kept attacking and there was chance after chance. That happens at all levels in England, barring when teams park the bus, in which case it's more like a regular Barca match, which is boring IMO.
Yes, it can be argued that the EPL has a more entertaining style of soccer. What I'm arguing is that La Liga has better teams and better talent.

Mandieta6 said:
I don't rate Almeria, personally, or Malaga. But, whatever.
Okay, I don't rate Birmingham City then. See how easy it is to blow off a good point?

You brought up Birmingham City's newly promoted run, said it doesn't happen in Spain, and I gave you two examples of when it recently did happen.
 

Xifio

The Von Trapps
hah, Az's arguments in this thread are quite the laugh ... there's no need to argue against them; they are a joke unto themselves ... I read "skill is fleeting" somewhere in his posts? that actually made me lol ...

if his argument was solely based around the fact that he prefers a basketball-type back-and-forth game of football, then fine, to each his own ... but the rest of the stuff -- not least about England and their "proper mentality" -- is just such, well, there isn't much point talking about it ...

anyway, it is great that he likes the unskilled (or was it less-skilled?), hardworking type ... it is great he considers calling someone a "wonderkid" to be derogatory ... coz I'd be mildly concerned if he liked the same things I do ...
 

Dytza

Banned - Playing with Fire
Xifio;2809525 said:
hah, Az's arguments in this thread are quite the laugh ... there's no need to argue against them; they are a joke unto themselves ... I read "skill is fleeting" somewhere in his posts? that actually made me lol ...

Some of his quotes are very funny. This one has to stick together with "Barça football is boring."
 

Xifio

The Von Trapps
Dytza;2809600 said:
Some of his quotes are very funny. This one has to stick together with "Barça football is boring."
actually, like I mentioned in my previous post, I can understand -- not agree with, but understand -- if he finds Barcelona's style boring; he wants a fast, end-to-end, basketball-type game ... far too often teams -- including his beloved Chelsea -- don't have the balls to try and provide entertainment for the fans by taking on Barcelona in an open, attacking game ... so they park the bus, and hope for a lucky break (pun intended); again, that is their prerogative ... and yes, it can be very boring to watch Barça try and get round a bus for 90+ minutes ...

even his argument for the Cristiano Ronaldo vs. Messi elbow I don't have a problem with; heck, I think the height of the players point is valid ...

no, the part I commented on in my last post has to do with the topic of this thread: La Liga ... it is Az's comparison of Spanish football and players to the English game and its players that I find to be ludicrously funny ... I mean some of his arguments are just baseless bilge ... but he is megalomaniac -- or at least a wannabe megalomaniac, with egocentricity driving his online persona ... as is usual with such people, they are not only opinionated, but walk around believing that they know best, and everyone else is an idiot ... so all you can do is laugh and move on ...
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
Sevillista;2809488 said:
Canales is a major force somewhere, namely a city called Santander. He has the team and fans excited and winning. They're 8-2-1 in their last eleven matches since he started tearing it up, and you know he doesn't have much of a team behind him.

The fans hate him now, by the way. And he's still not a major Spanish force, and I would love for Del Bosque to take him to the World Cup, because I'd bet anything he'd be the Spanish Walcott.


Or you can have fun watching them while they're lighting it up. Even if they don't reach their potential, in your words there are new wonderkids every season. Why discredit what they're doing now based on hypothetical future flops?

I never said the wole wonderkid situation was bad, or lacking in entertainment. It was just a point about how Spain's homegrown talent seems much better at first, when in reality the the level, when looking at their careers as a whole, is similar.

All of these arguments are generalized or based on a hypothetical future. Just because Spain has a lot of "wonderkids" doesn't mean they don't have dependable/disciplined/well-rounded players. Both leagues have them in spades. You seriously think 80% of La Liga's players are "crappy" and 90% of England's players are average?. Then there is no point in discussing this with you anymore.

My argument was based on my observations on the development of English and Spanish players through the years. Of course Spain has well-roudned players, but I definitely think the average Spanish player isn-t as well-rounded as an English one. No, that was hyperbole. But I think England's bell-curve on the player-level axis would be lean more towards the right than its Spanish equivalent.

England's NT may have older players, but where has that gotten them? You argue that Spain goes through cycles and by comparison England has more stability. What is that based on? England has not had more success than Spain, unless you want to go back to 1966.

My point about the player age had noting to do with the levels of success of both countries, it was there to corroborate my point about the player development curve of the different players. Be it for good or bad.
Again, you're stating something that is "definite", but you have nothing to back up your argument. What makes you say the EPL is more diverse? Sevilla, for example, has players from Mali, Serbia, Lithuania, Ivory Coast, France, Brazil, and Argentina. We have better homegrown talent, but that doesn't mean we have an excess of it. Spanish soccer is very diverse:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_foreign_La_Liga_players

Spain has foreign talent, but on an average matchday, the ratio of homegrown to foreign players will be much higher than in England. You just have to look at the squad lists to see that. Wasn't one of Calderon's points to make Real Madrid more Spanish? That wikipage certainly has a lot of foreign players, but look at how many of them are current players? Very few. By my count about 170. There are roughly 250 active foreign players in the Premiership according to Wikipedia. That's a pretty big difference.

What I mean is that the game is much tighter, allowing fewer passing lanes.

I wouldn't say that's bad. It's all down to what you like to see. I enjoy watching good defensive work.

Yes, it can be argued that the EPL has a more entertaining style of soccer. What I'm arguing is that La Liga has better teams and better talent.

And I'm fine with that. I disagree.

Okay, I don't rate Birmingham City then. See how easy it is to blow off a good point?

You brought up Birmingham City's newly promoted run, said it doesn't happen in Spain, and I gave you two examples of when it recently did happen.

It is indeed easy.

Xifio;2809525 said:
hah, Az's arguments in this thread are quite the laugh ... there's no need to argue against them; they are a joke unto themselves ... I read "skill is fleeting" somewhere in his posts? that actually made me lol ...

if his argument was solely based around the fact that he prefers a basketball-type back-and-forth game of football, then fine, to each his own ... but the rest of the stuff -- not least about England and their "proper mentality" -- is just such, well, there isn't much point talking about it ...

anyway, it is great that he likes the unskilled (or was it less-skilled?), hardworking type ... it is great he considers calling someone a "wonderkid" to be derogatory ... coz I'd be mildly concerned if he liked the same things I do ...

I'm glad that I can entertain you. Skill is fleeting. Players do 'lose it', not least because they are no longer physically capable of doing what they used to do.

I enjoy the football those who are less skilled, or to put it better, less flashy, but physically better offer. That's why I value a player who can keep going for 5 more minutes more than a player who can pull off a few dribbles. Being a wonderkid isn't derogatory at all, I'm just saying that not all the wonderkids reach their potential, which is why at first glance Spain might seem to have a batch of world-beaters coming up every year, in the overall, the level is the same.

Dytza;2809600 said:
Some of his quotes are very funny. This one has to stick together with "Barça football is boring."

The fact that someone who is incapable of having an opinion much less expressing it, is laughing at my posts is disturbing. I respect Xifio and Sevillista because they actually think for themselves, and know their ****, but you are just pathetic. If you didn't have the other supporters to play off of you would not have a single post under your name. Come back when you have an actual opinion.

Xifio;2809611 said:
actually, like I mentioned in my previous post, I can understand -- not agree with, but understand -- if he finds Barcelona's style boring; he wants a fast, end-to-end, basketball-type game ... far too often teams -- including his beloved Chelsea -- don't have the balls to try and provide entertainment for the fans by taking on Barcelona in an open, attacking game ... so they park the bus, and hope for a lucky break (pun intended); again, that is their prerogative ... and yes, it can be very boring to watch Barça try and get round a bus for 90+ minutes ...

even his argument for the Cristiano Ronaldo vs. Messi elbow I don't have a problem with; heck, I think the height of the players point is valid ...

no, the part I commented on in my last post has to do with the topic of this thread: La Liga ... it is Az's comparison of Spanish football and players to the English game and its players that I find to be ludicrously funny ... I mean some of his arguments are just baseless bilge ... but he is megalomaniac -- or at least a wannabe megalomaniac, with egocentricity driving his online persona ... as is usual with such people, they are not only opinionated, but walk around believing that they know best, and everyone else is an idiot ... so all you can do is laugh and move on ...

Right, we parked the bus and carved out no chances whatsoever. The Chelsea match has become notorious because we actually defended properly. But that's not the issue here, I've already gotten into both the Chelsea-Barca argument and the Barca-style argument before, with the same people, no point in doing it again.

I am arrogant and believe I know best, got no problem with that. But I wasn't being as arrogant as I normally am this time. I never even insinutated that what I'm saying is fact, but I'm not going to follow-up every thing I say with 'IMO'. This entire argument was prefaced with the notion that this argument is entirely based on opinion, and people using facts, observations, opinions, etc. to corroborate those.

But my point about the way players are brought up in England and Spain is not baseless at all. I'll see if I can find the BBC article when an FA worker stated that England would benefit from putting more emphasis on technique than the other aspects of the game, because few wonderkids are coming up through the ranks. He thought that was a bad thing, I don't. It's also simply based on my observations on the players in both leagues, and I think it explains the differences between them.
 

Dytza

Banned - Playing with Fire
Mandieta6;2809911 said:
The fact that someone who is incapable of having an opinion much less expressing it, is laughing at my posts is disturbing. I respect Xifio and Sevillista because they actually think for themselves, and know their ****, but you are just pathetic. If you didn't have the other supporters to play off of you would not have a single post under your name. Come back when you have an actual opinion.

Actually I have opinions. The fact that I didn't get into such a subjective discussion is another problem. If you observed, I refuse to argue against you since the "ban incident" (which btw, still didn't happen:clapwap:) since you don't accept other opinions but yours!
 


Top