Giggs vs. Nedved

[Alex]

Originally posted by mhflierman
What a comparison. Let's compare Friedel and Van Nistelrooij after this. They may both be attackinig midfielders, but they don't play the same position. If you had compared Scholes and Nedved that would have made sense. This doesn't.

Yep my thoughts exactly...

Giggs is a LW..Nedved is a LCAM, CAM, or maybe LAM...

 

[valioso]

Originally posted by ryan_goal
hey, be fair to one of my former idols!

yeah he rarely goes around defenders but sometimes he does, not NEVER. the sweetest one is the one when we lost to Real Madrid in 2000. it's just a superb goal by becks after he beat a few defenders. well, i dont suppose u watch too many of manu games anyway.

Actually I watch as many man u games as I can. and I like Beckham as a player, but be fair here, he is not fast, and he doesnt dribble all that well.. yeah he may go around a defender here and there, but most of the times he doesnt even try.

 

[Hans]

Talent = Giggs
Determination = Nedved

 

[mhflierman]

Originally posted by valioso
......but most of the times he doesnt even try.

He doesn't have to, he just bends the ball around the defender and still provides it with unseen accuracy and pace...

 

[valioso]

if u had read the previous comment I made, I said he has the best right leg in the world right now.
But he can not dribble around defenders, like other players that play on his position. Beckham shouldnt be playing as a right wing in the first place.

 

[R0D]

even playing in a little different positons, i think giggs is better than nedved
they're both gr8, but my personal vote goes to giggs, because that guy knows how to carry the ball....

I think we should vote on who has the worse hairstyle, as both of them have some bad cuts, but my vote'd go to neved for having a basin mullet...

i'm sorry for asking that in public, but are u gay?

what about overmars? he is the fastest player of the world!

 

[cyrex]

Pavel Nedved is the best midfielder after Zidane.

 

[kisho]

Nedved all the way, he defend, attack, he is like Roberto Carlos, Giggs is a good player in bad year, but even in his best year he could not aproach Nedved's level

 

[LazioEagle]

Originally posted by JeffBoy15
LazioEagle, I'm a big fan of Claudio Lopez, could you help me make a sig or avtar?

U think my sig and avatar r great??

 

[JeffBoy15]

It's not bad, the ones i make are crap

 

[Silverhawk]

Originally posted by kisho
Nedved all the way, he defend, attack, he is like Roberto Carlos, Giggs is a good player in bad year, but even in his best year he could not aproach Nedved's level

1.Roberto Carlos is baaaaaaad.
2.Giggs is old.a coupla years ago,i'd say he was the best winger in the world,except figo then.

 

[johnnyboyuk]

See I always hate "who's better X or Y...." because it's impossible, you cannot compare players. Nedved and Giggs are two very different players. In his time Giggs would be the first choice winger of anybody's team. To be honest, I've not really seen a great deal of Nedved only about 4/5 games. He's a good player yes, but I hear of him spoken as a god of football?? not sure he's THAT good.

Different players have different styles. Giggs' style is excellently adapted to Utd where he gives and go's and is a good team player. In Juventus Nedved plays an almost playmaker role and more of the play solely revolves around him, therefore comparisons cannot really be made.