SG United

[rpvankasteren]

Ok, it's time I started serious work on this. What would you guys prefer? A randomised team (maybe CA/PA/position could be predetermined), or a full submission like in 01/02 days?

Also, please do write down anything you'd like to add for me to consider. I'll definitely take any idea into consideration.

 

[Stotty]

How many stats are there that would need submitting by players ruud?

 

[Daz]

I'd suggest some kind of mix between the two. as in have technical, physical and the majority of mental abilities to be random but with predetermined CA. But then maybe have a selection of mental attributes (such as aggression etc.) and maybe others such as loyalty to be selected by the applicant, although if they're all ridiculously high the mod has the right to lower some.

CA and PA i think should be judged on each member's post count, reputation and how often they're specifically on the FM forum.

 

[Stotty]

But then maybe have a selection of mental attributes (such as aggression etc.) and maybe others such as loyalty to be selected by the applicant, although if they're all ridiculously high the mod has the right to lower some.

Just have a points total which can be split between each stat like in previous years.

 

[Dreath]

I don't think completely randomised stats be much fun. Like i'd like to be given high determination, pace, acceleration and strangth. Because Those are my strengths. It'd make the game the game more personal'

Say if you could post 5 stats which are to be your strengths. Then your potential ability could be decided on random, but based on how known you are.

For instance- Post count 18,000, well known. Pot ability between 170-190. Or something like that.

 

[Stotty]

I dont think post count should be taken into account. It should either be first come first served like a few years ago, or categorized like last year.

 

[rpvankasteren]

Post count alone is no reason to give someone high CA/PA. I'd never give someone like Silencer high CA/PA if he'd sign up, even though he has like 12k posts. Quality before quantity.

 

[Daz]

well then we should use the judgement of the "senior" members of the FM forum to judge PA

 

[Zlatan]

I think the way it was done last year is the best way; choose a few stats(2 or 3 or somethin') which are set to 16/17 as default and the rest all randomised.

 

[nor-rbk]

I think the way it was done last year is the best way; choose a few stats(2 or 3 or somethin') which are set to 16/17 as default and the rest all randomised.

I agree with that one.

But I also think we could use our usernames here on SG instead of our real names. Since our usernames here are our "SG names" if you understand me. And also because then everyone know who each player on the team are on the forum (since not all know everyone's real name).

 

[Áļéאָ]

I cant believe you still have the strength to do this again this year man! lol
Anyways, just come online on messenger some times. Might figure out a way how i could.. give you an extra hand.

 

[rpvankasteren]

Someday... no promises, though. Maybe monday.

 

[Hopeunited]

I agree with Zlatan. But maybe 5 or 6 attributes to be made strong like 15 instead of just 2 or 3.

 

[yoyo913]

I would like to do another SG team, i could help if its wanted

 

[Fernandez]

Just have a points total which can be split between each stat like in previous years.

It'll be a pain for Ruud and co. to count the total points

 

[PSVFOREVER]

Just give us 20 for everything , with the handyman option

 

[Kibe Kru]

I liked last year's system, it seemed to work alright... made a good challenge to take the team to promotion, compared to previous versions... I don't know how much of a trouble Ruud had to get the CA/PA stuff done though...

 

[adj137]

yes!, my vote puts Submission form in the lead 4 to 3.

i agree with nor-rbk, i don't know how tedious it would be but like everyones username could be put in as their nickname, with their real name in the profile if they wanted to give it.

 

[fender]

Voted for random.

 

[Zlatan]

Yeah but than you think like WTF?Zlatan in SG United?
No just keep it at the real names, if really necessary you can set the username in the real name or something.