Best Management Game?

[Sir Calumn]

Out of the three management games covered by these forums, which is your favourite?

This has been posted in all the management games forums, vote for your favourite and if possible, reply and tell us why it is better that the others!!!!

If Championship Manager gets beaten I may consider buying the winner!!!!

-C

 

[.::John::.]

It's CM for many reasons. Simplest interface- You don't have to click 5 menus to get where you're going like on TCM (and this will be even easier in CM4 with keyboard shortcuts). It had the most players, the most staff, the most complex attributes (mental, ability etc.) An editor, (not sure if the other ones have these). And CM4 will be skinable!

 

[Áļéאָ]

I think the question should be which is no2! My vote is CM no1, and Football Man 2002 no2. TCM sucks!

 

[flamehawk]

same as what I said in the TCM forum---

Well, itz not really any better game. Its personal preference I guess, and I know probably more people would prefer CM, I myself like TCM better.

I might be wrong but I think that TCM 2003 is much more editable. Considering so far there are database patches for almost everysingle country except for oddities such as Macao etc. But there is even singapore and Hong Kong. TCM 2003 may not have came with a big database but it is very editable. You can control league regulations, kit designs etc. And TCM 2004 will be even better with the FIFA 2003 engine with stadium editor, newspaper etc.

I also think that the youth management is way better. Anywayz the 2 games are very different so I don't think it is really too comparable although I just kind of compared it.

But you may consider taking Football Manager out of the poll because itz pretty much TCM 2002 they jsut changed the name.

 

[veron28]

Champion manager


[COLOR=royal blue]Its without a doubt the best. there is no contest, Champ wins anyday[/COLOR]

Do you like my grooooooooovy post

 

[.::John::.]

Originally posted by veron28
Do you like my grooooooooovy post

Not really, the colours hurt my eyes

 

[voetballiefhebb]

Bit biasd posting on a CM forum, post it on the TCM forum. Hmm...

 

[Sir Calumn]

Originally posted by voetballiefhebb
Bit biasd posting on a CM forum, post it on the TCM forum. Hmm...

It has been posted on all the management forums

-C

 

[veron28]

Originally posted by ChelseaFan88
It has been posted on all the management forums

-C

Yeah but are the results we can see on this thread just the results from the cm forum or r they all the results put together?

 

[voetballiefhebb]

Originally posted by ChelseaFan88
It has been posted on all the management forums

-C

You make me sick!

I demand you are yellow carded

 

[Ebonix]

Originally posted by voetballiefhebb
You make me sick!

I demand you are yellow carded

Ohh ok only if you say so sir

I voted CM (wonder why )

 

[monkeyhappy]

CHAMPIONSHIP MANAGER NEVER DOUBT IT!!!!!!!!

on a lighter note have a nice day

 

[Áļéאָ]

I thik we should also ask about LMA. It was my first ever football managment game

 

[Ebonix]

Originally posted by mixafendis
I thik we should also ask about LMA. It was my first ever football managment game

do you mean getting a LMA forum?

That maybe a good idea but it's getting other mods, supermods and admin to agree with it.
It may not be popular enough, Look at the total club manager forum

 

[Áļéאָ]

You're right. CM is my favourite, but if i hadn't played LMA , if u asked me what CM is, well i'd say "How should i know?". I realy liked LMA, I remember right after the 2d game, waching the very good 3D higlits of the game... I could also choose Sponsors for the team shirt. Right after Cm (in my opinion) it is the 2nd best managment game

 

[veron28]

Originally posted by mixafendis
You're right. CM is my favourite, but if i hadn't played LMA , if u asked me what CM is, well i'd say "How should i know?". I realy liked LMA, I remember right after the 2d game, waching the very good 3D higlits of the game... I could also choose Sponsors for the team shirt. Right after Cm (in my opinion) it is the 2nd best managment game

Yeah LMA is my second fav managment game.

 

[voetballiefhebb]

Originally posted by veron28
Yeah LMA is my second fav managment game.

USM98 is mine.

LMA is good, takes too long though. Alex Ferguson managerial game is also good.