1)Fix referee signals - I have never seen a referee switching flag from hand to hand above his head.It looks totally weird.Then a referee signal before penalty.He is never standing on the penalty kick point and pointing with his hand down. + add the names of the assistants too and made them not to look like triples.
2)Stadium closer to the side lines - there's just so much space behind the goal line.
3)Defender in Arena - I would like to have a defender in the Arena,it would be great to train the new tricks on a defender.The goalkeeper is using his hands and always fouls my player when I make the skill move.
4)Adding animations - fourth referee showing substitutions and added time,celebrating fans,winning cups celebration, etc...
5)Players going down when tackled in penalty area - I don't like when the player just stops his run without fall and it's a penalty.
6)Player growth when they are on a loan to another club
7)Choosing different socks for kits
8)Youth Academies of the club
9)Player make mistakes.Even player with all abilities on one is able to stop every ball perfectly.
10)Improve celebrations - the number of celebrations is okay,but do something with the other players.They're just standing next to you and are not happy for the goal.
I just want improvements on game modes, like be a pro and dirigent mode..
Would be nice to transfer for another team in the middle of season, receive offers, etc. in both modes, not forgetting that on be a pro you can't even transfer and you spend just 4 seasons playing, you start on the 1st team, you don't have to practice, etc..
I played Fifa11 alot over the last year, as i am sure you all did, but went and got pes11 last month just to compare. This is what fifa 12 needs:
More of a real 'Manager Mode' experience: - a season just feels like one game after another, it has no development of players, no training schedules, no youth team to pick from an develop.
i would like to see a 'post match comment' that gives your team + or - form or recovery time etc.
it needs players to come forward and say they want more game time or want a transfer or payrise etc
it needs a better transfer and scouting system.
Also, have shots or clips of in the locker rooms, the manager talking to players etc, etc like pes11 does.
also, with be a player-manager mode, you should be able to change clubs and take player with you (or sell him off and change to manager mode)
Be A Pro improvements: 'be a pro' is OK but 'become a legend' mode in pes is better. the coach actually tells you what he wants you to do (eg, hold possession, attack the left wing. etc). again, it feels like just one match after another. otherwise, it ok.
game play: I'm not really an expert with the trick-stick, but there needs to be an improvement here. I would like to see a system where a) the left trigger responds faster and b) left trigger put you into a 'controlled dribble' mode where the more skilled the player is the better he is at controlling possession in tight spaces. it feels like you cant use skillful players properly.
Also more controls for when a player is shielding a ball.
Crossing from edge of the box needs to be improved. i use manual controls because the auto cross assist can only find a defender.
Less outside of the boot shots and weak foot shots when normal shooting will do.
Maybe a training section with mini-games for learning/be a pro/manager mode? where you can improve dribbling or speed skills by running around cones on the field or improve free kick acc or swerve by hitting targets from free kicks etc (kinda like old pes5 game i played)
i dont really play online, so i cant comment on that but i hope the improved player AI will help. i also hope the new collision system doesn't suck.
PES makes you feel like you are playing football or a manager of a team. But FIFA plays better...much better. a few little improvements and FIFA could be the best.
(also use the whole screen when in menu's!!!! unlock vintage teams/matches, and more!!!!)